I’ve written on here before concerning the exceedingly black image that most of contemporary society has of Ancient Egypt. A lot of these views are based on old stereotypes from Hollywood, the press hysteria over the “Mummy’s Curse” surrounding the tomb of Tutankhamun (a.k.a. “King Tut”) and views based on the myths and folktales of an entirely different culture (I.e. Exodus).
Archaeology and study of Egyptian literature and administrative documents long ago dispelled these black myths, but the public perception lingers. This may be because that much of work done in translation and excavation is published in journals and books that are largely inaccessible and undesirable to the general public because of it’s highly academic nature, and many of the specialist publications are also not available in more general bookstores. Meanwhile increasing amounts of information come from TV, whose study of Egyptian culture is limited to Hollywood blockbusters or embarrassingly bad “edutainment” documentaries that focus on the sensational.
However, what good is research if it’s huge advances in understanding utterly pass by the general population, whom still cling the notions of the sneering Pharaoh keeping his slaves in line with the lash?
I am interested in getting some views and comments on this, so please debate!
February 5, 2009 at 10:59 am
Hi
I would quite agree that the impression offered by mainstream culture has very little to do with the lives of ancient Egyptians and I’m researching a period of Egyptian culture which is a good example. The Third Intermediate Period – XXIII to XXVI dynasties when women – Black women mainly – ruled Upper Egypt is a fascinating period of history. When a woman in true power was also listening to the word of Amun – as Oracle – and offering advice to her public regarding everything from conception of children to long-lost loves.
In addition to which (in this case a Queen called Amenirdis I) ruled Upper Egypt more carefully – tactfully – and brought stability, wealth and Peace for approximately forty-six years.
Keep up the good work!
February 6, 2009 at 10:22 pm
Hello Pavements. I am sorry for being away from my dear cyber life for so long. I hope you like my come back, I’m starting to discuss Ancient Egyptian spirituality in a dialogue/story format. I wonder what youll think about it.
About the video blog, I like the idea but I had trouble following. Maybe you speak too low or my ears are not as trained in English as my eyes
I’m mentioning this since you might have many non-native speakers on your blog.
Another thing, you might like to raise the camera so it gives the impression we re talking face to face, rather than your being talking down to me (figuratively n literally
).
The topic you know I agree on what you say, but maybe I need a more heated angle so my debate urge rises enough to start a debate
(note: I only saw the first video now)
I think you need to be more confrontational if you want a debate to start: “The public believes this [and you show us the movie or article or whatever on the screen] but in fact this is what seems to be the truth [showing another thing]“. Add mockery and youre done
February 6, 2009 at 10:34 pm
Ok, I saw the second part. I have a cpl of comments:
1. Maybe if you did a series of videos, like the Neter series, each time telling something, small and specific, to address a specific issue, but in an attractive format, angle or story, that would help.
2. I think instead of attacking National Geographic you can inform them by articles that they would publish. I have a NG-published photographer to supply the pics, and a whole team of people who can join your trips if you want. And I guess I can help you find an interesting angle if you supplied the info, I can turn it into a story or journalistic thing. How do you like that?
March 3, 2009 at 12:50 am
Heya! Welcome back, stranger! I’ve been out of touch too. It’s the end of term panic, when you realise you spent a year swanning around, doing the odd assignment, and suddenly the heat is on. The next 2 weeks should be…educational!
Thanks for the comments. I’d like to do a series of videos. The quality is low, I agree. I was using the built in webcam on my laptop so the height couldn’t be moved much, and the mic amplification is weak too. I do have DV cam with NICAM audio support that Tara uses for documentary stuff, so if I can prise it from her hot little hands, I might be able to use that in future! Hopefully that should improve the quality a little bit.
As for bitching about NG, I actually use them a simply as one name to symbolise an issue. It’s something that bothers me, but I really haven’t found a solution yet! I’d like to do a proper presentation about it, like you suggest, but I really don’t have the expertise, time and resources to dedicate to it at this point in time. I guess I’m really hoping to get people thinking about it, in the hope people in a better position than me might make a move, or at least give me some thought for a future project when I myself am in a better position time/money/expertise wise.
May 29, 2009 at 7:32 am
Pavements,
Great blog! I need to link you from my own humble proto-blog.
Regarding Egypt’s image, I would have to agree 100% that most of what passed for “Egyptology” well into the latter half of the 20Th century was agenda-driven.
At first the agenda was a hamfisted attempt to drive the round peg Egyptian history into the square hole of Judeo-Christian pseudo-history.
Then, in what I am almost tempted to call a backlash, you have various New Agey type groups who tried to impose their spin, although I have to admit that I feel the latter group moved the ball in the right direction more than the former.
I certainly have no problem with theoretical research regarding Ancient Egyptian spirituality. My own initial interest revolved around exploring the mythological contributions which Egypt made to the roots of the Judeo-Christian faiths, which I think are distant cousins to the Egyptians.
My problem is with the attempts to assimilate those myths and then treat them as if they are your own actual, literal history. Thats where we get wrongheaded notions of Hebrew slaves builing the pyramids, when in fact we have found the villages and graves of the workers and there is much evidence that the work was done by very skilled, and very free, labor.
When I was in Cairo I spent some time with someone who was affiliated with a group called the Friends of the Future of the Past. I did a cursory search for them recently for an article I was writing, and could find nothing on the web, but more digging might yield better results. This was ten years ago, and they may have changed their name, but I think they would be right up your alley. If I find anything about them I will post it here.
Sorry, didn’t mean to ramble!
But good job!